Perceptions of Inclusion: A Study of Children with Autism in the Primary School

Children with a diagnosis of Autism experience difficulties in social communication and are vulnerable to bullying and social exclusion in mainstream schools.

The importance of educating all children in an inclusive learning environment is enshrined in both national and international legislative policy (UNESCO, 1994; Department for Education, 2015).

Yet, the numbers of children with Autism currently facing exclusion from their mainstream schools are disproportionate compared to children with other Special Educational Needs (SEN) (Department for Education, 2018; Ambitious about Autism, n.d.(a)).

As a construct, 'Inclusion' is multi-dimensional and is expressed through full participation in the wider community, a sense of belonging and being part of a wider social group (Farrell, 2000).

There is ambiguity regarding how this concept operates in practice. How children relate to others and the social repertoires they display are likely to be a core component to effective inclusion.

Peer-Mediated Interventions (PMIs) have been used to promote the social skills of children with Autism.

A systematic review of the literature was undertaken to examine the evidence from eighteen single-subject experimental designs (SSEDs).

These studies examined the effectiveness of PMIs on improving the social outcomes of children with Autism.

The review made an original contribution by using the 'What Works Clearinghouse' (WWC) Design Standards for evaluating SSEDs (Kratochwill et al., 2010).

All studies reviewed showed positive findings, yet conclusions drawn were tentative. There was considerable variability across the studies regarding the role of peers.

Generalisability of findings were limited by a lack of long-term follow-up data.

Outcome measures were focused on behavioural modification, and although helpful, over-simplified the complex nature of social interaction.

The conclusions from the systematic review identified the need to further explore peers' perceptions and the contextual environment in which inclusion is practiced.

Chapter Two focused on exploring the experiences and perspectives of children with Autism, their peers and their teachers in the social environment of the school playground, and examined how inclusion operated in this context.

Using a qualitative case study design and semi-structured interviews, children with autism, their peers and their teachers were interviewed in three different Primary Schools (n= 39).

To capture peers' perspectives of autistic behaviours, modified vignettes were used as a stimulus for discussion (Butler & Gillis, 2011; Matthews et al., 2015).

Findings suggested that children's experiences of playground inclusion were more alike than different for all child participants.

Specific environmental barriers to inclusion were identified as lack of structure in the playground, and within-child factors such as difficulties in emotional regulation and social communication.

Facilitators were identified as increased adult support and a wider range of play equipment for some children with autism, although the need to recognise the individuality of each child was highlighted.

Peers' understanding of autistic behaviours presented in the vignettes were variable and included hostile attributions (Dodge, 2006).

Further research could explore the development of peer attributions of autistic behaviours and examine how these directly impact upon peer interaction in the playground.

Implications for practice were highlighted, including the need to reflect about how EPs can support schools in educating children and staff about autism and how our attributions of difference can affect our behaviour towards others.